NEIGHBORHOOD OF THE WEEK
No. 01 | Windsor Forest, Williamsburg, Virginia
Windsor Forest: Nearly 25 Years of Calling This Special Neighborhood Home
Some neighborhoods are places to live. Others become part of your life.
By John Womeldorf | Mr. Williamsburg

Welcome to Neighborhood of the Week!
After 25 years selling real estate throughout Greater Williamsburg, I’ve accumulated quite a collection of neighborhood stories.
Over the years, I’ve written detailed guides covering dozens of communities, from established neighborhoods with decades of history to brand-new developments just beginning to take shape.
One feature I’ve always tried to incorporate into these guides is useful, up-to-date real estate information. Most include live feeds displaying all current homes for sale and recent home sales, allowing readers to explore a neighborhood and keep tabs on its real estate market long after the original article was published.
But neighborhoods are much more than houses and sales statistics.
They evolve. Trees grow taller, homes change hands, families come and go, amenities improve, and occasionally an entirely new generation moves back into the very neighborhood where they grew up.
So I thought it was time to revisit some old favorites.
Welcome to Neighborhood of the Week, a new series where I’ll take a fresh look at the communities that make Greater Williamsburg such an interesting place to call home.
We’ll explore their histories, architecture, amenities, real estate markets, and perhaps most importantly, the little things that give each neighborhood its personality.
I’ll also share links to my comprehensive neighborhood guides, where you can explore current listings, recent sales, and additional community information.
And since I get to pick the first one, I’m starting with a place that’s especially near and dear to my heart.
My own neighborhood: Windsor Forest.
There’s No Place Like Home

I’ve called Windsor Forest home for nearly a quarter of a century.
It’s where Lisa and I raised our two sons, Zachary and Josh. They learned to ride their bikes on these streets, made lifelong friends, and spent countless summer afternoons at the neighborhood pool.
Both boys swam for the Windsor Forest Frogs, starting when they were just six years old and continuing through their senior years of high school.
Over the years, I’ve also had the opportunity to give back to the community in a variety of ways. I served on the Windsor Forest Association board for more than a decade, volunteered to manage the neighborhood pool for 10 years, and took on numerous other Association responsibilities along the way.
And then there’s my professional connection to Windsor Forest.
Of the neighborhood’s 365 homes, I’ve had the privilege of selling nearly 40 of them — representing more than 10% of the entire community. In fact, I’ve sold several of those properties more than once as families moved in, moved on, and new owners began making memories of their own.
That’s a lot of front doors, kitchen tables, home inspections, moving trucks, and wonderful people I’ve gotten to know along the way.
So when I tell someone about Windsor Forest, I’m not simply repeating information from an MLS listing or neighborhood brochure.
I’ve lived it, volunteered for it, raised a family in it, and helped dozens of others make it their home.
And after nearly 25 years, I still think it’s one of Williamsburg’s special places.
A Little History: A Developer Who Got It Right
Windsor Forest began taking shape in 1971, the vision of local developer Robert S. Hornsby Sr.
Hornsby wasn’t simply a builder. He was an active member of the Williamsburg community, serving on the William & Mary Alumni Association board, as a trustee of Williamsburg Community Hospital, and as president of the Golden Horseshoe Club.
His vision for Windsor Forest was refreshingly different from the approach we see in many modern subdivisions.
Rather than clear-cutting the property and squeezing in as many houses as possible, the development was designed around the natural contours of the land, preserving mature trees and creating generously sized homesites.
The community encompasses more than 321 acres, with lots generally ranging from approximately half an acre to more than an acre.
Hornsby eventually passed the reins of the development company to his son, Bobby Hornsby, who continued the family’s work. And here’s something I particularly like: Bobby still lives in Windsor Forest to this day!
There’s something to be said for a developer who believes enough in the neighborhood his family created to call it home himself.
The community continued developing into the mid-2000s, with custom builders creating an interesting mix of architectural styles.
You’ll find traditional two-story Colonials, transitional designs, contemporary homes, and plenty of custom touches.
One of my favorite things about Windsor Forest is that you can drive down an entire street without seeing two identical houses.
Imagine that!
More than 50 years after development began, the original vision has aged remarkably well.
And Here’s a Little Williamsburg Trivia…

Speaking of the Hornsby name, have you ever heard of Bruce Hornsby?
Of course you have! Or at least I’d bet you’ve heard some of his music.
The Grammy Award-winning singer, songwriter, and pianist burst onto the national music scene in the late 1980s with Bruce Hornsby and the Range, giving us hits like The Way It Is, Mandolin Rain, and The Valley Road.
What some people may not realize is that Bruce grew up right here in Williamsburg and, after all these years and an extraordinary musical career, still calls the Williamsburg area home.
He’s one of my personal favorites.
His music has always had a sound that’s difficult to pigeonhole — a little rock, jazz, bluegrass, Americana, and just about everything in between. He’s also collaborated with an incredible range of musicians over the years, including the Grateful Dead.
If you’re not familiar with his work, do yourself a favor and look him up on Spotify or your favorite streaming service.
You can thank me later!
Listen to Bruce Hornsby on Spotify
Now, back to Windsor Forest…
The Trees, the Lots, and That Established Neighborhood Feeling



If you’ve spent much time touring newer construction around Williamsburg, you know that generous lots and mature landscaping aren’t always part of the package.
Windsor Forest offers both.
The trees are enormous now. Many homes sit comfortably back from the street, and the natural wooded areas provide a sense of separation without making the neighborhood feel isolated.
There’s something wonderful about walking beneath a canopy of trees that has taken decades to develop.
The neighborhood also has sidewalks, something surprisingly uncommon in several of Williamsburg’s other established residential communities.
And location is another big advantage.
Situated off Longhill Road between Centerville Road and Route 199, Windsor Forest offers convenient access to Colonial Williamsburg, William & Mary, New Town, shopping, restaurants, and the surrounding region.
It feels tucked away, yet you’re never particularly far from anything.
The Heart of Windsor Forest? I’d Have to Say the Pool.


Ask longtime residents about their favorite Windsor Forest memories, and I suspect a remarkable number of those stories will involve the pool.
The neighborhood recreation complex includes a 25-meter competition pool, diving well, baby pool, clubhouse, playground, tennis and pickleball courts, and a soccer field.
But listing the amenities doesn’t really tell the story.
The pool is where friendships are formed, kids grow up, neighbors catch up, and summer evenings have a way of stretching well past dinnertime.
Friday evenings have long been a neighborhood tradition. Families gather, pizzas arrive, and before you know it, you’ve spent several hours catching up with people you originally stopped by to say hello to for five minutes.
I volunteered to manage the pool for 10 years, so I’ve seen firsthand how much work goes into keeping everything running.
And I can tell you that a community like this doesn’t happen by accident.
It takes volunteers, dedicated board members, swim team parents, social committees, and residents who care enough to contribute their time.
Once a Frog, Always a Frog!

The Windsor Forest Frogs deserve their own mention.
For generations, the swim team has been a central part of neighborhood summers.
Our two sons practically grew up on that pool deck, and I watched countless other children do the same.
Over the years, dozens of former Frog swimmers have gone on to compete at the collegiate level, including scholarship athletes. One former Frog even competed in the Olympics.
But the medals and records aren’t what I remember most.
It’s the early mornings, the swim meets, the parents volunteering, the kids cheering for one another, and the friendships that lasted long after everyone stopped swimming competitively.
And today, some of those former Frogs are back in Windsor Forest with children of their own.
Which brings me to something I find particularly remarkable about this neighborhood.
They Grew Up Here. Then They Came Back.
In my original Windsor Forest neighborhood article, I mentioned that more than 19 families living in the community had actually grown up here before returning as adults.
Think about that for a moment.
They went off to college, started careers, got married, explored other places, and eventually decided that the neighborhood where they spent their childhood was where they wanted to put down roots again.
In some instances, three generations of the same family have called Windsor Forest home at the same time.
I can’t think of a much better endorsement for a neighborhood.
Of course, Windsor Forest isn’t just about families with children. It’s a wonderful mix of longtime residents, newcomers, working professionals, empty nesters, retirees, and people at all different stages of life.
That variety is part of what makes it interesting.
A Neighborhood That Knows How to Have Fun

If you think neighborhood associations are just about collecting dues and maintaining entrance signs, you haven’t spent much time in Windsor Forest.
There’s a long tradition of getting together.
Over the years, neighborhood activities have included Easter celebrations, pool parties, Christmas caroling, visits from Santa, holiday decorating contests, Wine Wednesdays, ladies’ luncheons, and clubhouse gatherings.
And then there’s the Fourth of July parade.
Decorated bicycles, wagons, costumes, neighbors lining the streets — it’s a wonderfully old-fashioned tradition that reminds me of the kind of community celebrations many of us remember growing up.
Christmas is another favorite.
We even have a Griswold Award for enthusiastic holiday decorating.
If you’ve seen National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation, you get the idea.
Some people take their decorations VERY seriously!
But perhaps my favorite thing about Windsor Forest is what happens when there isn’t a scheduled event.
Neighbors simply look out for one another.
The neighborhood’s From the Heart Club helps coordinate meals and short-term assistance for residents dealing with illness, surgery, or loss.
New residents are welcomed, longtime friendships are maintained, and there’s a genuine sense that people care about the place they share.
That’s something you can’t build with bricks and lumber.
The Windsor Forest Association: Keeping the Community Going
The Windsor Forest Association plays an important role in maintaining the community’s amenities, appearance, and social traditions.
Membership is voluntary, and resident participation helps support everything from neighborhood landscaping to recreational facilities and community activities.
The Association also publishes The Forester, a neighborhood newsletter that helps residents stay connected.
Its website contains a particularly telling collection of comments from residents explaining why they choose to support the organization.
Some mention the amenities. Others appreciate the landscaping, volunteer efforts, or the Association’s work representing neighborhood interests.
Several talk about something much simpler: belonging.
The Association is also keeping residents informed about the Longhill Road widening project, including its impact on neighborhood entrance improvements and signage.
Having served on the board for more than 10 years myself, I have a particular appreciation for the volunteers who keep things moving behind the scenes.
For current information, Association membership, pool rates, and community news, visit:
Windsor Forest Association Official Website
What About Windsor Forest Real Estate?





Naturally, I can’t write about a neighborhood without putting on my Realtor hat for a moment.
Windsor Forest has 365 homes, and its housing stock is wonderfully diverse.
Unlike communities where most houses were built within a relatively short period, Windsor Forest offers homes constructed across several decades.
That means buyers will encounter everything from beautifully preserved traditional homes to extensively renovated properties with contemporary kitchens, updated bathrooms, and redesigned interiors.
And, yes, occasionally a home that’s ready for someone to roll up their sleeves and bring it into the 21st century.
My background in construction and remodeling has always made that aspect of Windsor Forest particularly interesting to me.
A home with good bones, a generous lot, and a great location can offer opportunities that aren’t always apparent in the listing photographs.
Pricing varies considerably depending on size, condition, updates, lot characteristics, and other features. That’s why I encourage buyers and sellers to look beyond neighborhood averages and evaluate individual properties.
Having personally sold nearly 40 of the neighborhood’s 365 homes, including several more than once, I’ve had the opportunity to see how different properties compare, which improvements resonate with buyers, and how the market has evolved.
Curious What Homes Are Selling for in Windsor Forest?
One of the features I’ve incorporated into most of my neighborhood guides over the years is a live real estate feed.
Rather than relying on a static list of properties that quickly becomes outdated, these pages feature continuously updated information, including:
- All current homes for sale in the neighborhood.
- Recent home sales, including actual selling prices.
- Property details, photographs, and other available listing information.
Whether you’re considering a move, wondering what your neighbor’s house sold for, or simply keeping an eye on your home’s value, it’s a great resource.
Explore Windsor Forest — Current Homes for Sale, Recent Sales & Complete Neighborhood Guide
And remember, automated estimates and neighborhood averages only tell part of the story. I’m always happy to provide a more personalized perspective on what your particular property might be worth.
The Mr. Williamsburg Perspective
Every installment of Neighborhood of the Week will include my personal perspective — something you probably won’t find on Zillow, an HOA website, or a typical real estate listing.
And for Windsor Forest, that perspective is pretty simple.
I’ve spent nearly a quarter of a century here, and Windsor Forest has been much more than simply the place where I receive my mail.
I’ve watched my children grow up, neighbors become friends, friends become grandparents, and former neighborhood kids return with families of their own.
I’ve volunteered countless hours serving on the Association board, managing the pool, and helping with the behind-the-scenes work that keeps a community like this going.
And professionally, I’ve had the privilege of selling nearly 40 of Windsor Forest’s 365 homes — more than 10% of the entire neighborhood. A few of those homes I’ve even had the pleasure of selling multiple times!
I suppose you could say I know Windsor Forest from just about every angle: as a homeowner, parent, volunteer, neighbor, and Realtor.
But after all these years, what stands out most isn’t the real estate. It’s the people.
The best neighborhoods aren’t necessarily the ones with the fanciest entrances, newest clubhouses, or most expensive homes.
They’re the ones where people feel connected. Where neighbors look out for one another. Where friendships last for decades, and where kids grow up with memories so good that they eventually decide to come back.
That’s Windsor Forest to me.
And while I might be a little biased, I think Robert Hornsby would be awfully pleased with what his neighborhood has become.
Explore This Week’s Neighborhood
WINDSOR FOREST | WILLIAMSBURG, VIRGINIA
Want to learn more? My comprehensive Windsor Forest neighborhood guide includes additional history, community information, photographs, and live real estate feeds featuring current listings and recent home sales.
VIEW THE COMPLETE WINDSOR FOREST NEIGHBORHOOD GUIDE
You can also visit the Windsor Forest Association for information about membership, recreation, neighborhood activities, and community news.
Do You Have a Windsor Forest Memory?
I’d love to hear from current residents, former residents, and especially those who grew up here.
Were you a Windsor Forest Frog? Do you remember the old Fourth of July parades, summer nights at the pool, or a particularly memorable Christmas decorating competition?
Maybe you grew up here and eventually returned to raise your own family.
Share your memories in the comments. Better yet, dig out some old neighborhood photographs!
I’d love to make this first installment of Neighborhood of the Week as much about the people who made Windsor Forest special as the neighborhood itself.
And stay tuned. Next week, we’ll revisit another Greater Williamsburg neighborhood with its own history, personality, and stories worth telling.
After all, Williamsburg is much more than Colonial Williamsburg. It’s the communities and people that surround it that make this such a wonderful place to call home.
About the Author
John Womeldorf | Mr. Williamsburg
With 25 years of experience selling real estate throughout Greater Williamsburg and the surrounding region, John combines extensive local knowledge, a background in construction and remodeling, and a genuine passion for the communities he serves.
A longtime Windsor Forest resident and Realtor with Liz Moore & Associates, John writes about Williamsburg neighborhoods, real estate, local history, new developments, restaurants, and the people and places that make this region special.
Thinking about buying or selling in Greater Williamsburg? Let’s talk.
Phone/Text: 757-254-8136
Email: John@MrWilliamsburg.com
Website: MrWilliamsburg.com
Your real estate journey is personal. It deserves to be treated that way.