If you’re selling a home this spring, knocking $1,000 off your list price might net you thousands of dollars more at the closing table. If you’re buying, adding $1,000 to your offer could help you elbow out rival bidders in a market that the coronavirus has made surprisingly competitive.
And if you want to boost your chances of selling your home above its list price, hire an experienced agent — and be sure that agent crafts enthusiastic marketing copy for the comments section in the multiple listing service.
Those are among the home-sales hacks discovered by housing economists Michael Seiler and Bennie Waller. Seiler is a professor of real estate and finance at the College of William & Mary in Williamsburg, Virginia, and Waller, a professor of finance and real estate at Longwood University in Farmville, Virginia.
Their findings were reported in peer-reviewed research and published in academic journals. Their work, conducted separately, gives a glimpse into the quirks of human behavior in housing markets.
You probably learned in economics class that buyers and sellers are perfectly rational and that prices of homes or any other good take place at the bloodless intersection of supply and demand. Seiler and Waller, don’t believe that’s the last word.
The two academics are among a cadre of researchers who are looking for quirks in the way consumers buy and sell homes. “Buyers and sellers are not always rational,” Waller says. “You saw it in the mid-2000s. People were buying properties way above list price.”
Seiler, also a visiting professor at Harvard, says his academic training taught him that humans are logical actors, but his research has disabused him of that notion. “My entire career is based on the fact that there are psychological factors at play,” he says. “We’re not all robots.”
Use ‘just-below’ pricing of your property
There’s a reason retailers price items at $99 rather than $100: The first digit in the price has a strong influence on a potential buyer’s mindset. That bit of consumer psychology applies not just to shirts and appliances but also to home prices, Seiler says.
Knocking a list price down from $300,000 to $299,000, or from $200,000 to $199,000, ultimately yields a premium of 2.5 percent to 3 percent when the home sells, Seiler says. However, he says, cutting the list price from $250,000 to $249,000 won’t net a seller more. “It’s the left-most digit that really matters,”.
Seiler co-authored a piece in the Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics based on a study of more than 372,000 transactions in the Virginia Beach-Norfolk region from 1993 through 2011. The concept remains a potent one today, he says.
“People can see the difference is only $1,000,” Seiler says. “Even though in the short term, your brain knows exactly what you’re talking about, later, the one that’s priced just slightly higher seems much higher.”
For buyers in bidding wars, the concept works in reverse, he adds. To make your bid stand out, offer $300,000 instead of $299,000.
There is a drawback of doing just-below pricing, Seiler acknowledges: Buyers tend to search properties in increments of $25,000 or $50,000, so a list price of $199,000 might not appear in searches of buyers shopping in the $200,000 to $250,000 range.
When selling, hire an experienced agent
For a separate study in the Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, Waller and his co-authors scrutinized nearly 102,000 sales in the Richmond, Virginia, metro area from 2001 to 2015. They wanted to know why some properties sell above list price.
One crucial variable is the experience of the agent, they found. Agents in Waller’s study had been in the business for 13 years on average, and veterans were more likely to sell above list price than rookies. “You want a more experienced agent, one who knows the nuances, knows where the hot spots are,” Waller says.
Alas, veteran Realtors aren’t miracle workers. They’re simply less likely to take overpriced listings, and more adept at talking down sellers with unrealistic expectations. “Experienced agents aren’t going to take a property that’s overpriced, particularly if they’re incredibly overpriced,” Waller says. “It’s a waste of time, and it hurts their reputational capital.”
Another factor to keep in mind: The structure of real estate commissions motivates listing agents to sell quickly but not to hold out for top dollar, Waller says. An extra $10,000 in the seller’s pocket fattens the agent’s commission by only $200 or so.
Agent comments matter, agent bonuses don’t
Waller also found that the number of comments written by the agent when describing the listing affects whether it sells for a premium. The more comments, the better.
However, offering cash bonuses or more generous commissions to agents who secure buyers doesn’t seem to matter in terms of generating premium prices. Conversely, offering cut-rate commissions to buyer agents does reduce the likelihood a property will sell above list price.
Even after crunching the numbers on more than 100,000 listings, Waller acknowledges that some mysteries remain. “One of the things I wish we could disentangle was why properties were underpriced,” Waller says. “We don’t know if it’s a divorce. We don’t know if it’s a job situation. Those who underprice might have a need to dump the property.”
And there’s also the role of what Waller calls “dumb luck.” This is more common in higher-end homes, which linger longer on the market while the seller waits for just the right buyer. “Sometimes,” he says, “the buyer and seller just come together.”
A little about Mr Williamsburg
Psssst! I wanted to let you in on a little secret. While I am a real estate agent…I am a different kind of real estate agent. I am creating a revolution in realty by combining everything you love about this area all into one place. Known around town as Mr. Williamsburg, I combine my extensive knowledge of the Williamsburg, Richmond, and Hampton Roads areas with my expertise in helping buyers and sellers navigate the ever-changing local real estate market to create a top-notch experience that checks all of your boxes.
Are you a homeowner searching for someone innovative and committed to selling your home? Allow Mr. Williamsburg to tell your story. With my unique marketing approach, your home will be seen from your eyes, not described in a few sentences by someone who doesn’t know it well.
Curious in finding the value of your existing home? Ask me here.
Interested in learning more about neighborhoods in the Williamsburg area? Check out my resource on specific communities in the surrounding areas of Williamsburg and Hampton Roads here.
Looking somewhere other than Williamsburg? In addition to my affinity for Williamsburg, I have helped hundreds of folks find their dream home and community in areas outside of the ‘Burg, such as Yorktown, New Kent, Virginia Beach, Chesapeake, Suffolk, Isle of Wight, Poquoson, and Richmond. I’m committed to helping you find your perfect fit and the place you’re happy to call home. Fill out this form and I’ll get back to you so we can connect.
Want to learn more about what working with me is like? While I can tell you all day why I love what I do so much, hearing directly from previous clients is the best way to see this. To read real client reviews and learn more about what it’s like working with me on your team, visit my reviews page here.
Your real estate journey is just that…yours. I get that it’ll be unique. It needs a marketing plan and a committed real estate professional to guide you every step of the way. To talk further, you can reach me via phone or text at 757-254-8136 or through email at [email protected].
I look forward to serving your real estate needs and welcoming you to this place that I’m lucky enough to call home!
John Womeldorf, Mr. Williamsburg